Our Art Collection – Comrades by Robert Gibb


An ionic image of the military art genre is Comrades by Robert Gibb (b.1845-d.1932), which was first exhibited at the Royal Scottish Academy in 1887. The location of this original painting is now unknown.

Whilst studying the life of Napoleon, Gibb had made a sketch of the retreat from Moscow. The dominant group of three figures in the foreground was then isolated and adapted to form an independent composition depicting a young solider whispering a dying message to a comrade who seeks to comfort him amidst the snowy wastes of the Crimean winter. It was during the winter of 1854-5 that The Black Watch suffered particularly heavy losses from the severe weather and disease. The original Comrades picture was purchased by Archibald Ramsden, a major patron of Gibb, and it was recorded to be in his possession in 1897. The Museum holds a fine autograph replica by Gibb in oils, signed and dated 1894. This replica painting of Comrades is located in the Empire Gallery on the first floor of the Museum. This work is of national significance given the disappearance from public records of the 1878 original.

Additionally the Museum has a spectacular piece of Scottish stained glass with a design deriving from Comrades and portraying a Seaforth Highlander standing guard over two Black Watch soldiers. Its original provenance is unknown. Thethis can be seen when visiting the Remembrance Memorial on the ground floor of the Museum.

This piece was written using research conducted by Helen Smailes, Senior Curator of British Art at the National Galleries of Scotland and Alan Carswell, our redevelopment external project manager.




About blackwatchmuseum

The Museum of The Black Watch offers an insight into one of the British Army's if not the world's most famous fighting units. Scotland's Black Watch is an elite military regiment whose history stretches back almost three centuries.
This entry was posted in Artefacts and collections, Our art collection, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Our Art Collection – Comrades by Robert Gibb

  1. John Canny says:

    I noted that the location of the original Gibb painting entitled Comrades is not known!

    I had the pleasure of viewing the original last week on the RDS club in Dublin.

    It has pride of place in the gallery at the top of the main stairs in the club and is often commented on. The club has a catalogue of the clubs art works in the main lounge.

    John Canny (Falkirk Bairn) living in Enniskerry, Co Wicklow

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s